Adam and EveAnswered

Did the Church Fathers teach that the devil tempted Adam before Eve?

TL;DR

Robert Sungenis answers that he knows of no Father who taught that the devil tempted Adam before Eve, and that even two or three would not make a consensus, unlike the Fathers' unanimity on geocentrism. He adds that the idea makes little sense, since the text says Eve gave the fruit to Adam and he also ate.

A viewer relays that Father Ripperger said the devil tempted Adam first and Adam refused, according to the Fathers of the Church, and asks Robert's view.

Answer

With all due respect to Father Ripperger, whom I love, I would have to disagree, because I have never come across a Father who says that. And even if you found two or three, that is not a consensus. The Fathers were not inspired; they worked from what was handed down from the apostolic oral tradition and synthesized it as best they could, so before you say 'the Fathers say,' you need a dozen or two dozen saying the same thing. On geocentrism you do have that consensus, because every Father who addressed it defended a motionless earth in the middle, even against the Pythagorean heliocentrists. But this idea that Adam resisted first and then Eve fell does not even make sense, because the very next verse says 'and Adam also ate.' Eve gave it to him and he ate. He cannot resist at one point and then lose all sensibility when Eve is tempted. So on that one I would have to say no.

Answered by Dr. Robert Sungenis

Related Questions