If every pope would say canonized saints are in heaven, isn't that unanimous tradition making canonizations infallible?
A viewer asks whether, since every pope would affirm that a canonized person is in heaven, this amounts to a unanimous tradition that makes canonizations infallible.
Answer
No. Unanimity is first applied to the patristic era. In other words, the Council of Trent, Vatican I and Vatican II all said the same thing: that if the Fathers of the Church are in unanimous consent on a particular doctrine of faith or morals, that means unanimous. If there's a hundred Fathers, it doesn't mean there has to be a hundred, but 99, 98, 95, close to that, because the Church is not going to put a number on it. So that's where it first comes from. Why? Is it because the Fathers themselves have authority? No. It's the apostles who are the authority. That's why the Church calls it apostolic oral tradition. Unless you're a Gospel writer or St. Paul, you're not going to be writing down a whole lot as an apostle, but you're going to be talking a lot. And what they authorized as apostles would filter down through the Church, a lot of times to the very people we call the Fathers of the Church. The early ones would be Polycarp, Papias, Ignatius, very early, and the Epistle of Barnabas, all in the first century. And then you have Fathers coming after them, Irenaeus, Justin Martyr, and so on, and then Fathers in the third century and so on. And if they are in unanimous consent on a doctrine of faith or morals, well, then we assume they got that from the apostles. The apostles taught them, transferred it somehow, and that's why all the Fathers believe the same thing. There is no unanimous consent if a few popes get together and say, hey, what do you think of this issue here? Do we agree on this? No, that's not unanimous consent. Let's say when Benedict XVI retired, or we could say abdicated the papacy, could he talk to Francis afterwards and give his advice? Sure, he could. Personally, maybe, but not doctrinally, because he's just another person. Now he's just a member of the Church like everybody else. He doesn't have any power or authority as Pope Emeritus Benedict, as strange as that seems. The question of canonizations has to be settled by the official magisterium. We have to stop assuming that canonizations are infallible when there is no place in the testimony of the Church that declares that canonizations are infallible. And how could you say that somebody that the Church has said is in heaven could not be in heaven, or destroy the sensitivity we have to what's official and what's not official? Yeah, that's right. So stop pussyfooting around and start declaring whether it's infallible or not. Stop guessing. If you're going to declare someone in heaven, then you'd better have that doctrine made infallible, and not just say it's infallible or think you can say it's infallible. "This has been declared infallible by Pope So-and-So" would make the whole infallibility issue a lot easier to swallow and stop causing confusion. If the Pope would say at the end of his letter, or whatever he wants to write, this is an infallible statement, declared by the present Pope, I myself, John, whatever, the 27th, on this day, blah, blah, blah, then there's no guessing game anymore. Oh, is this infallible? We all argue back and forth, and we have no authority at all except to give our opinion. So if you're going to use the doctrine of infallibility, then use it. It's God's gift. But you have to make it clear. There is no more discussion. That's the actual meaning behind something being declared infallible: it means you can't discuss this anymore. It's not open for opinion anymore. It's done. The door has been left open because we don't have that clear language, and somebody needs to do something about it.