Papal AuthorityAnswered

What do you think of Pope Leo XIV?

What do you think of Pope Leo XIV?

Answer

There is much that could be said about Pope Leo XIV. As always, I judge a pope according to how faithfully he preserves and defends the deposit of faith handed down from the apostles. A pope’s authority is real and binding, but it is not absolute. It is bounded by divine revelation, sacred tradition, and the consistent Magisterium of the Church. When a pope speaks or acts within that framework, Catholics owe him obedience. When he speaks outside of it, we must respectfully withhold assent. If Pope Leo XIV upholds the traditional teachings of the Church on faith, morals, and the natural law, then he exercises his office properly and is to be supported. If, however, he introduces novelty or ambiguity that obscures doctrine on issues such as the uniqueness of the Catholic Church for salvation, the immorality of contraception, or the proper understanding of ecumenism, then Catholics have a duty to recognize that such statements are not protected by infallibility and must be evaluated in light of prior magisterial teaching. Every pope, including Pope Leo XIV, is the servant of tradition, not its master. His role is to confirm the brethren in the faith, not to alter the faith. So my view depends entirely on whether he has remained faithful to the unbroken line of teaching that extends from Peter through the centuries. If he does, he deserves our full allegiance. If he departs from it, then our allegiance is first to Christ and His revealed truth, as guarded and defined by the perennial Magisterium of the Church.

Dr. Robert Sungenis