Old Testament InterpretationAnswered

Why was David not punished for acting like a priest when Uzzah was struck dead?

TL;DR

Robert Sungenis answers that Uzzah, struck dead in 2 Samuel 6, touched the Ark, which only priests could handle, while the king punished for acting as a priest was Uzziah, who burned incense in 2 Chronicles 26. He holds that David never usurped the priesthood: he ate the consecrated bread out of real need, which Jesus defended, and God sees the difference between humble need and pride.

A viewer named Charlie from Delhi asks why David, when he acts like a priest in 1 Samuel 21, is not punished, while his descendant is punished for acting like a priest.

Answer

The key is to keep the two men straight, because they are easily confused. The one struck dead for touching the Ark was Uzzah, in Second Samuel chapter six. He was not a priest, and when the oxen stumbled and the Ark began to tip he reached out and took hold of it. On the surface that looks like he was helping, but the law was clear that no one but the priests was to touch the holy things, and God struck him on the spot, so that even David became afraid. Uzzah was not acting like a priest; he was handling what only the priests were permitted to handle. The man who was actually punished for acting like a priest is a different person: King Uzziah, in Second Chronicles chapter twenty-six. When he grew strong he became proud and went into the temple to burn incense on the altar, which belonged to the priests alone, and God struck him with leprosy that he carried to the day he died. That is the real case of a king reaching into the priestly office and being judged for it. So why was David not punished? Because David did not usurp the priesthood the way Uzziah did. When he ate the consecrated bread it was out of genuine need while doing the Lord's work, and Jesus Himself later defended it against the Pharisees, teaching that the Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath. The sacred things are good when they are used rightly, for man's true benefit. And when David moved the Ark and Uzzah died, David took the lesson to heart: the second time, he had the Levites carry it the way God had commanded, with fear and reverence. God sees the heart, and He knows the difference between a man acting in humble need and a man grasping at an office out of pride.

Answered by Dr. Robert Sungenis

Related Questions