ConscienceAnswered

Can I bear guilt for not admonishing a repeated grave sin after my confessor advised me not to?

A viewer asks whether they bear any guilt for not admonishing someone's repeated grave sin, given that their confessor advised them not to admonish the person.

Answer

No, because unless it's a sin in and of itself, your confessor is not going to determine whether this is a sin. He can only give his opinion. But if you're struggling with whether what you did is a sin, well, you need to go to your pastor, or talk to the bishop, talk to somebody in authority who knows whether this is a sin or not. If you're having difficulty figuring it out, your confessor could certainly help. But he's not legally tied to you. Your pastor and your bishop are. If you wanted to, maybe the pastor or the bishop can give you the name of a moral theologian that you might want to talk to. And in our day and age, it's easy to talk to them. Just find out their email address, get your pastor's or bishop's approval to contact them, or have the moral theologian contact you. It depends on how serious this is to you.

Answered by Dr. Robert Sungenis

Related Questions