What is entropy, and does it bear on the heat problem and the age of the universe?
A viewer follows up on the heat problem, conceding Robert's point but pressing the question of entropy.
Answer
So here's an issue that I thought was settled. But the question is, what is entropy? And you get various explanations of entropy. One popular one is that entropy is a movement toward increasing disorder. That used to be a succinct definition of entropy. In a general way, yeah, entropy would have to be something close to that, because it's certainly not going to be toward increasing order. We know that things left to themselves are not going to repair themselves or become better machines or more efficient. That just usually doesn't happen. And that applies to organic mechanisms like the human body or inorganic mechanisms like the gasoline engine. The other explanation is that entropy is dealing with heat. And heat is what you get when the mechanism is functioning as it's designed. But if the mechanism is contained, the molecules are rubbing against one another as it functions. Like the gasoline engine: the piston's going up and down in the cylinder, compressing the gas, it's ignited, it explodes. But you also get a lot of heat escaping from that engine. In other words, for the amount of gas and the energy that it makes, we're not going to get 100% to that crankshaft. We're only going to get about 30% of it. So that's not a whole lot. And where's the other 70%? Well, that escapes as heat and goes into the atmosphere. So that's entropy, because you have a heat escape. If there was no entropy, then you would have the heat confined, and it would do additional work. Let's say it heats up coal and starts to burn coal, I don't know. You could have that. But that's what the second law of thermodynamics really is: it's basically a transfer of heat from one place to another. That's what entropy is. So if that happens, then it's a natural process. The sun is an example, we think, of converting hydrogen to helium, because it lets off heat. That's how we get heat from the sun. So that's entropy. Well, there is so little hydrogen turned into helium that the sun could last another five billion years when you calculate it all out. So the entropy is taken into account, let's say, when the sun is created, so that it lasts a long time. It's not going to disappear before we all die. So we don't worry about it. So you can have entropy in the universe and it's not going to harm anything. It's just a natural process. Stars are the same way. They could last for billions of years. That's how they're built. You even have entropy in the orbit of the moon around the earth. It does lose distance. And that's a form of entropy, because the gravitational pull on the moon does not compensate for the speed of the moon and the irregular orbit the moon has. So that means the moon is going to move away by four centimeters per year. Now that may not be a whole lot now, but you add four centimeters up over millions of years and you're not going to have the same moon that we have today. It's not going to be 235,000 miles away. It's going to be 500,000 miles away. That's a little more worrisome than the sun running out of what it needs to keep burning. And that kind of gives you an example of what kind of world God made, at least locally. If the moon plays its part, then you have to have a moon that's been in its orbit less than, say, a million years. It can't be billions of years if it's moving away at four centimeters per year. That's all going to catch up someday. And you would wonder, has God built other things into the creation that would last 6,000 years, 10,000 years, and that's it? The earth's magnetic field is constantly deteriorating, and some estimates are like 10,000 years. That's it. It's going toward increasing disorder. The magnetic field is not generating what it normally would, because it's dissipating. That's another thing to look at. So that whole question about entropy needs to be contextualized before you answer a question like the one you're posing here. All right, enough science.